An empty brown cicada shell clinging to a tree is a record of a successful change of stage. The insect that occupied it climbed out as a winged adult. It did not begin life that evening: much of its growth had already taken place out of sight below ground.
Following that hidden stage explains why a loud summer adult can have a short adult life and still be a long-lived insect.
The young cicada feeds underground
Female cicadas place eggs in plant material. After hatching, the small young, called nymphs, reach the ground and burrow into the soil. CSIRO describes them feeding on root sap and remaining underground for several years in some species.
Nymphs grow through successive moults. Their digging front legs and wingless form suit life below the surface; they are not miniature flying adults waiting in the soil with folded, usable wings. Sap is taken through specialised piercing and sucking mouthparts, rather than by chewing pieces from a root.
The final climb leaves the familiar shell
When ready for the adult stage, a nymph reaches the surface and climbs a vertical support such as a tree trunk. CSIRO describes it fastening its claws to the bark and shedding the outer covering. The adult emerges, leaving that covering, or exuvia, attached behind it.
An empty shell is therefore different from a dead adult. It cannot tell you how many of the emerged adults later survived, and a collection of shells is not by itself a count of singing males. It records a particular part of the life cycle at that place.
Cicadas undergo incomplete metamorphosis. As the Museum’s metamorphosis guide explains, insects in this group have nymphal stages and a final moult, without a pupal stage. A butterfly’s caterpillar-to-pupa-to-adult sequence is a different developmental route; a cicada shell is not a chrysalis.
There is no single Australian cicada clock
The Australian Museum cautiously describes six or seven underground years as a suggestion for some common, large Australian species. That is not a measured timetable for every cicada in every garden. The famous 13- and 17-year periodical cicadas are North American examples, not a universal explanation for Australian summer choruses.
For a more local example, the Museum’s Greengrocer account describes nymphs growing underground for up to seven years and adults emerging on warm nights, often following rain, between September and November. Adult Greengrocers live around six weeks. Those are species-specific details, not dates to apply to all Australian cicadas.
Greengrocer and Yellow Monday are also names for different colour forms of the same species, Cyclochila australasiae. Two colours on nearby trees do not necessarily represent two species.
Watch the change where it happens
Leave an emerging cicada on its chosen support and give it room. Do not peel it from its shell or move it for a photograph. You can record the date, weather and tree or other support without touching the insect.
If the shell is empty, look at the split and the strong front legs from a distance. They are clues to the underground animal that reached this point, while the adult’s wings mark the next stage. The summer song is conspicuous; the growth that made it possible mostly was not.